Tax Liability cannot be imposed merely because the financial statement did not provide State-wise turnover

editor — Thu, 04 Apr 2024 10:14:35 +0000

The imposition of tax liability solely based on the absence of state-wise turnover information in financial statements has been contested in the legal realm. This matter was addressed by the Hon’ble Madras High Court in a recent case involving Tvl. Future General India Insurance Co. Ltd. versus Assistant Commissioner (State Tax) [WP No. 3534 OF 2024, dated February 16, 2024].

Facts:

Tvl. Future General India Insurance Co. Ltd. (“the Petitioner”) operated as a private general insurance firm, specializing in insurance services. On August 16, 2021, the Petitioner was served with an audit notice by the Assistant Commissioner (State Tax) (FAC) (“the Respondent”). In response, the Petitioner diligently furnished the necessary documents and addressed the discrepancies highlighted in the audit reports. Subsequently, after issuing both an intimation and a show cause notice (“the SCN”), the Competent Authority issued the assessment order on December 30, 2023 (“the Impugned Order”).

Within the Impugned Order, the issue of defect No. 10 arose, relating to variations in turnover between the Profit & Loss account and balance sheet, as opposed to the figures in GSTR-9. The Petitioner explained that these disparities stemmed from the inclusion of Pan-India operations in the financial statements, whereas GSTR-9 solely focused on turnover within Tamil Nadu. The Petitioner even provided a certificate from a Chartered Accountant, specifically outlining the turnover within Tamil Nadu, amounting to Rs. 80,89,05,068/-. However, despite this clarification and despite the Petitioner having already paid taxes on the stated turnover, the Respondent imposed State Goods and Services Tax (SGST) and Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) at 18% each (36% combined) on the aforementioned turnover.

Dissatisfied with the assessment order, the Petitioner sought recourse by filing a writ petition before the Hon’ble High Court of Madras.

Top of Form

Issue:

The central question revolves around whether tax liability can be established solely due to the absence of state-wise turnover information in financial statements.

Held:

In its ruling on Writ Petition No. 3534 OF 2024, the Hon’ble Madras High Court made the following determinations:

The Court acknowledged the variation in turnover for entities operating across multiple states, emphasizing the importance of distinguishing total turnover from state-wise turnover.
It criticized the Competent Authority's decision to impose GST at a higher rate of 36% instead of the appropriate 18%, despite the Petitioner having already paid tax on the turnover in question.
The Impugned Order was deemed invalid and the case was remanded to the Respondent for reconsideration.
Furthermore, the Court directed the Respondent to afford the Petitioner a fair opportunity, including a personal hearing, and instructed issuance of a fresh assessment order within a maximum period of two months, in compliance with legal provisions.

Gross Direct Tax Revenues for FY24 Experience Notable Growth of 18.74%, net direct tax at 19.88%

editor — Wed, 20 Mar 2024 05:05:05 +0000

During the recent Budget speech, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman revised the projection for direct tax collections in FY24 to Rs 19.45 lakh crore, reflecting an increase from the initial estimate of Rs 18.20 lakh crore.

Gross Direct Tax Collections:

The provisional figures indicate an impressive growth of 18.74% in gross direct tax collections for FY24 compared to the previous fiscal year. Specifically, the gross collection of Direct Taxes (before refunds) reached Rs 22,27,067 crore, a substantial rise from Rs 18,75,535 crore in the corresponding period of FY23.

Net Direct Tax Collections:

Net direct tax collections from April 1, 2023, to March 17, 2024, experienced robust growth at 19.88%. The net collections amounted to Rs 18,90,259 crore, compared to Rs 15,76,776 crore in the corresponding period of the preceding financial year.

Composition of Net Direct Tax Collection:

The net direct tax collection of Rs 18,90,259 crore includes Corporation Tax (CIT) at Rs 9,14,469 crore (net of refund) and Personal Income Tax (PIT) including Securities Transaction Tax (STT) at Rs 9,72,224 crore (net of refund).

Advance Tax Collections:

Provisional figures of total Advance Tax collections for FY24 reached Rs 9,11,534 crore as of March 17, 2024, marking a significant growth of 22.31% compared to the corresponding period of FY23. Corporation Tax (CIT) accounted for Rs 6,72,899 crore, while Personal Income Tax (PIT) contributed Rs 2,38,628 crore.

Refunds:

Refunds totaling Rs. 3,36,808 crore were issued in FY24 until March 17, 2024, reflecting a notable increase of 12.74% compared to the previous fiscal year’s refunds of Rs. 2,98,758 crore.

Source: https://www.businesstoday.in/latest/economy/story/gross-direct-tax-collections-in-fy24-grows-at-1874-net-direct-tax-at-1988-422116-2024-03-19

CA in Jaipur | CA. Yogesh Jangid |ITR Filing 2023 | Company Registration | NGO Registration | Income Tax Raid Cases | Audit | Inc Incroporation | CPA in India | Subsidy | Project Funding | GST | GST Raid Cases | Income Tax Notice Faceless | DRI Cases |

Tax Liability cannot be imposed merely because the financial statement did not provide State-wise turnover

category

Gross Direct Tax Revenues for FY24 Experience Notable Growth of 18.74%, net direct tax at 19.88%

category